Top 10 Saltwater Fish to Catch in New York
Top 10 Species
These are the fish that get noticed by FishyAF anglers. Click any species to deep dive and learn more.
1
Striped Bass (Striper)
Verified
World Record
81 lb 14 oz
Gregory Myerson / 2011
Long Island Sound, Connecticut
Gregory Myerson / 2011
Long Island Sound, Connecticut
Signature Fact
Their eggs must stay drifting for about 48 hours-sink once, and the entire spawn suffocates.
2
Bluefish
Verified
World Record
31 lb 12 oz
James Hussey / 1972
Hatteras, North Carolina
James Hussey / 1972
Hatteras, North Carolina
Signature Fact
They practice brutal "surplus killing": slashing dozens of baitfish even with bellies bulging to the gills.
3
Black Sea Bass
Verified
World Record
10 lb 4 oz
Dennis B. DeMaria / 2010
Virginia Beach, Virginia
Dennis B. DeMaria / 2010
Virginia Beach, Virginia
Signature Fact
Most start as females, then the biggest 'boss' switches sex and grows that knothead hump anglers brag about.
4
Weakfish
Learn More Here Verified Catch
World Record
19 lb 2 oz
Billy B. Hahn / 1986
Delaware Bay, USA
Billy B. Hahn / 1986
Delaware Bay, USA
Signature Fact
Males beat superfast muscles on the swim bladder to "purr" loud enough to hear through a boat hull.
5
Bluefin Tuna
Learn More Here Verified Catch
World Record
1,496 lb 0 oz
Ken Fraser / 1979
Aulds Cove, Nova Scotia
Ken Fraser / 1979
Aulds Cove, Nova Scotia
Signature Fact
Bluefin run a built‑in furnace, keeping muscles, eyes, and brain up to 20°C warmer than seawater.
6
North Atlantic Cusk
Learn More Here Verified Catch
World Record
37 lb 11 oz
David A. Robinson / 1992
Jeffreys Ledge, Gulf of Maine
David A. Robinson / 1992
Jeffreys Ledge, Gulf of Maine
Signature Fact
The only North Atlantic codfish sporting a single, unbroken dorsal fin running almost nose-to-tail.
7
Wolfish
Learn More Here Verified Catch
World Record
52 lb 5 oz
Sigurður H. Magnússon / 1978
Iceland
Sigurður H. Magnússon / 1978
Iceland
Signature Fact
Its blood carries natural antifreeze, letting it swim in water cold enough to slush your guides.
8
Golden Tilefish
Learn More Here Verified Catch
World Record
63 lb 4 oz
R. D. Cummings / 1966
Ocean City, Maryland
R. D. Cummings / 1966
Ocean City, Maryland
Signature Fact
Underwater masons, they build shell-lined, rock-fortified burrows so dense they form "tilefish towns" visible on sonar.
9
Ribbon Fish
Learn More Here Verified Catch
World Record
11 lb 0 oz
Antonio J. Rodrigues / 2005
Portugal
Antonio J. Rodrigues / 2005
Portugal
Signature Fact
At up to 2.5 meters yet belt‑thin, it sometimes hovers vertically, powered by a scarlet‑crested dorsal ribbon.
10
Bluntnose Stingray
Learn More Here Verified Catch
World Record
374 lb 0 oz
Ivan L. Pate / 1992
Chesapeake Bay, Virginia
Ivan L. Pate / 1992
Chesapeake Bay, Virginia
Signature Fact
In Hypanus say, males seasonally grow spiky, gripping teeth for mating, then switch back to flat shell-crushers afterward.
FAQs
What fish can you catch in New York?
You’ll find striped bass, bluefish, black sea bass, weakfish, bluefin tuna, and more in New York’s saltwater.
What is the best time of year to fish in New York?
Spring through fall offers the best action for most saltwater species in New York.
Where are the best places to fish in New York?
New York’s saltwater coastlines and inshore waters produce great catches, but you won’t need secret spots to find quality fish here.
What gear do you need for fishing in New York?
Medium to heavy rods, tough reels, and strong line will handle everything from stripers and bluefish to black sea bass and tuna.
What are the easiest fish to catch in New York?
Black sea bass, bluefish, and sometimes striped bass are reliable targets for anglers looking for a solid catch.
